Free Consultation

Blood Test Defense

Many states have outlawed routine blood draws after a misdemeanor DUI or DWI arrest. In Texas, however, local law enforcement agencies have started forced blood draws after a suspect refuses to submit to chemical testing.

Called ”no refusal” weekends, these events are highly publicized in order to deter people from drinking and driving. In some cases, the person is strapped down and restrained by force while the blood is drawn with a needle.

Blood Test in Plano DWI

For attorneys, these type of cases presents a multitude of constitutional challenges that can be brought through motions to suppress the blood evidence and test results.

If you were subjected to blood draw after a DWI arrest by an officer with the Collin County Sheriff’s Office, or a police officer with the police department in McKinney, Frisco, Wylie, Allen or Plano, then contact an attorney with The Law Offices of Richard C. McConathy.


Overview of Fighting DWI Blood Test Results


Back to top

Constitutionality of Forced Blood Tests in Texas

The court of criminal appeals in Texas has explained that “the Supreme Court's holding in McNeely makes clear that drawing the blood of an individual suspected of DWI falls under the category of cases holding that ‘a warrantless search of a person is reasonable only if it falls within a recognized exception’ to the warrant requirement.” Villarreal, 2014 WL 6734178, at *20 (quoting McNeely, 133 S.Ct. at 1558) (emphasis added).

The court of criminal appeals emphasized that the McNeely Court “explained that such an intrusion implicates an individual's ‘most personal and deep-rooted expectations of privacy.’ ” Villarreal, 2014 WL 6734178, at *20 (quoting McNeely, 133 S.Ct. at 1558).

According to the Texas court of criminal appeals, “[t]hese principles from McNeely —the recognition of the substantial privacy interests at stake and the applicability of the traditional Fourth Amendment framework that requires either a warrant or an applicable exception—apply with equal force to this case.” Flores v. State, No. 04-13-00754-CR, 2014 WL 7183481, at *2 (Tex. App. Dec. 17, 2014); Villarreal at *20.

Thus, the court of criminal appeals “reject[ed] the State's assertion that a warrantless, nonconsensual blood draw conducted pursuant to those provisions [of the Transportation Code] can fall under one of the established exceptions to the warrant requirement.” Id. The court of criminal appeals further “reject[ed] the State's suggestion that such a search may be upheld under a general Fourth Amendment balancing test.” Id.

The Texas courts of appeals have found that a blood draw in a routine DWI case was not valid under the:

  1. consent exception to warrant requirement;
  2. automobile exception;
  3. special needs exception; and
  4. search incident to arrest exception.

Additionally, a blood draw is not valid as a general Fourth Amendment balancing test. Id.


Back to top

Challenging Results of a Consensual Blood Test

Many people ask, “I took a blood test for a DWI. Can I beat the case? What happens next?” Call our office for a free consultation so that we can answer your questions.

The issue in a DWI blood test case is whether the Assistant District Attorney with the Collins County District Attorney’s Office can get the breath test results into evidence at trial. In these cases, the defense will fight to have the results suppressed or excluded. If the results are admitted at trial, the defense will show problems with the results and its accuracy.

Challenges can be brought to the collection, storage, and testing of the blood sample with a machine known as a Gas Chromatograph.


Back to top

Finding A Collin County Attorney to Fight DWI Blood Tests

At The Law Offices of Richard C. McConathy, we will seek the best possible defense if prosecutors have the results of a blood test, including challenging the constitutionality of the test, bringing forth scientific evidence showing reasonable doubt about the results or more. Call an experienced criminal and DWI defense attorney at The Law Offices of Richard C. McConathy to discuss your case and your best defense.

Free Consultation
Our Office
map Plano, TX
5700 Granite Pkwy #200 Plano, TX 75024
View Map
5068 W Plano Pkwy #300 Plano, TX 75093
View Map
Allen, TX
1333 W McDermott Dr #200 Allen, TX 75013
View Map
Dallas, TX
15110 North Dallas Pkwy #400 Dallas, TX 75248
View Map
Primary office location in Dallas, TX
DWI Case Results
  • DWI Blood Test Case + Prescription Meds Dismissed (Cr200606211)
  • DWI Breath Test Case, Result Of .224 Dismissed (Mb0453171)
  • DWI Breath Test Refusal Not Guilty (005-84171-05, Ccl6)
  • DWI Breath Test Refusal Dismissed (1158539)
  • DWI, Open Container Dismissed (Mb0534487)
  • DWI, Accident + Open Container Not Guilty (M0524353)
  • DWI Dismissed, Refiled As Obstruction (M0460867)
  • 2nd DWI, Breath Test Refusal Dismissed (Mb-0262214-G Ccc6)
  • 3rd DWI Breath Test Refusal Dismissed (0913260d Cdc3)
  • Intoxication Assault, Breath Test Case, Result of .17 Dismissed (F09-52586)
  • DWI, Accident Not Guilty (M0538149)
  • DWI, Evading Police Not Guilty (M0640450)
  • DWI, Passed Out At The Wheel Not Guilty (Cr200707935)
View More Results
Client Testimonials

I was charged with DWI in Collin County, Texas. I heard that this is a tough place to get a DWI charge defeated. Fortunately, I hired Richard McConathy and Brian Bolton. They took it all the way and won my case. I owe these guys alot. Don't mess with any lawyer that can't compare with these guys. Thank you Richard and Brian.

William H. Collin County DWI
Proud Members Of These Organizations:
Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association
Dallas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association